Search results for: OCENA ARGUMENTACJI

• Expert assessment of arguments: a method and its experimental evaluation

  Publication

  • Ł. Cyra
  • J. Górski

  - Year 2008

  Argument structures are commonly used to develop and present cases for safety, security and other properties. Such argument structures tend to grow excessively. To deal with this problem, appropriate methods of their assessment are required. Two objectives are of particular interest: (1) systematic and explicit assessment of the compelling power of an argument, and (2) communication of the result of such an assessment to relevant...

  Full text to download in external service

• A method of trust case templates to support standards conformity achievement and assessment

  Publication

  • Ł. Cyra

  - Year 2008

  Osiąganie i ocena zgodności ze standardami stanowi poważne obciążenie finansowe dla współczesnych gospodarek. Pomimo znacznej wagi tego problemu, nie znalazł on jednak zadowalającego przełożenia na rozwiązania dostępne na rynku. W tej pracy zaproponowano metodę nazwaną Standards Conformity Framework (SCF), która wspiera stosowanie standardów. Jest ona oparta na spostrzeżeniu, że osiąganie i ocena zgodności ze standardem polega...

• Representing and appraising Toulmin model arguments in trust cases

  Publication

  • J. Górski
  • Ł. Cyra
  • A. Jarzębowicz
  • J. Miler

  - Year 2008

  The paper presents a Toulmin-based argument model used in trust cases, which allows to argue various properties of IT systems. Argument patterns encountered in trust cases are discussed together with some real-life examples. A method of argument appraisal is introduced together with the corresponding aggregation mechanism. Practical applications of trust cases in industrial and research projects are outlined.

  Full text available to download