Sensitivity analysis as a tool to optimise Human Development Index

Marta Kuc-Czarnecka

doi:10.24136/eq.2019.020

Sensitivity analysis as a tool to optimise Human Development Index

Abstract

Research background: Composite indicators are commonly used as an approximation tool to measure economic development, the standard of living, competitiveness, fairness, effectiveness, and many others being willingly implemented into many different research disciplines. However, it seems that in most cases, the variable weighting procedure is avoided or erroneous since, in most cases, the so-called ‘weights by belief’ are applied. As research show, it can be frequently observed that weights do not equal importance in composite indicators. As a result, biased rank-ings or grouping of objects are obtained. Purpose of the article: The primary purpose of this article is to optimise and improve the Human Development Index, which is the most commonly used composite indicator to rank countries in terms of their socio-economic development. The optimisation will be done by re-scaling the current weights, so they will express the real impact of every single component taken into consid-eration during HDI’s calculation process. Methods: In order to achieve the purpose mentioned above, the sensitivity analysis tools (mainly the first-order sensitivity index) were used to determine the appropriate weights in the Human Development Index. In the HDI’s resilience evaluation process, the Monte Carlo simulations and full-Bayesian Gaussian processes were applied. Based on the adjusted weights, a new ranking of countries was established and compiled with the initial ranking using, among others, Kendall tau correlation coefficient. Findings & Value added: Based on the data published by UNDP for 2017, it has been shown that the Human Development Index is built incorrectly by putting equal weights for all of its components. The weights proposed by the sensitivity analysis better reflect the actual contribution of individual factors to HDI variability. Re-scaled Human Development Index constructed based on proposed weights allow for better differentiation of countries due to their socio-economic development.

Citations

1 2

CrossRef
0

Web of Science
1 4

Scopus

Author (1)

Marta Kuc-Czarnecka dr

Cite as

Full text

download paper

downloaded 169 times

Publication version: Accepted or Published Version
License: open in new tab

Keywords

Details

Category:

Articles

Type:

artykuły w czasopismach

Published in:

EQUILIBRIUM Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy no. 14, pages 425 - 440,
ISSN: 1689-765X

Language:

English

Publication year:

2019

Bibliographic description:

Kuc-Czarnecka M.: Sensitivity analysis as a tool to optimise Human Development Index// EQUILIBRIUM Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy -Vol. 14,iss. 3 (2019), s.425-440

DOI: