Overview of the three multicriteria approaches applied to a global assessment of analytical methods

Paweł Mateusz Nowak; Paweł Kościelniak; Marek Tobiszewski; Ana Ballester-Caudet; Pilar Campíns-Falcó

doi:10.1016/j.trac.2020.116065

Overview of the three multicriteria approaches applied to a global assessment of analytical methods

Abstract

Critical and global evaluation of analytical methods should be one of the primary goals in analytical chemistry. A holistic approach, however, requires a look at the varied features: commonly discussed validation criteria, often underrated practical and economic aspects, and typically overlooked compliance with the principles of green analytical chemistry. Carrying out such an assessment in a critical and transparent way is extremely difficult without special tools. The purpose of this work is to discuss and compare the three different approaches that seem to be potential candidates: multi-criteria decision analysis methods (MCDA), HEXAGON, and RGB model. The basic principles of each methodology, individual possibilities offered, and the results of the assessment of selected model methods will be presented. Ultimately, the potential compatibility of assessing the same group of methods using different tools will be examined. This contribution can help to select optimal tool and conduct more thorough and insightful assessments.

Citations

6 5

CrossRef
0

Web of Science
6 2

Scopus

Authors (5)

Paweł Mateusz Nowak
Paweł Kościelniak prof. dr hab.
Marek Tobiszewski dr hab. inż.
Ana Ballester-Caudet
Pilar Campíns-Falcó

Cite as

Full text

download paper

downloaded 85 times

Publication version: Accepted or Published Version
License: open in new tab

Keywords

Details

Category:: Articles
Type:: artykuły w czasopismach
Published in:: TRAC-TRENDS IN ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY no. 133,
ISSN: 0165-9936
Language:: English
Publication year:: 2020
Bibliographic description:: Nowak P., Kościelniak P., Tobiszewski M., Ballester-Caudet A., Campíns-Falcó P.: Overview of the three multicriteria approaches applied to a global assessment of analytical methods// TRAC-TRENDS IN ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY -Vol. 133, (2020), s.116065-
DOI:: Digital Object Identifier (open in new tab) 10.1016/j.trac.2020.116065
Verified by:: Gdańsk University of Technology